Comments
Leaders not clueless, but corrupt
Victoria's economy irrevocabably linked to population growth
Victoria has joined Tasmania as the only states where economic output per resident is shrinking. When account is taken of Victoria's strong population growth, economic output per resident shrank 0.2 per cent in 2012-13. So, without population growth artificially propping up our State's economy, we would fall into recession! Victoria's standard of living almost certainly fell in this period with flat-lining gross disposable income. Victoria now has the second lowest gross household disposable income per person in the nation, ahead of only Tasmania.
SMH:Economic output rates shrink in Victoria, Tasmania
When combined with Ford’s announced closure last year, with a total of 1,200 job losses expected in Geelong and Broadmeadows by 2016, as well as thousands of potential job losses in the Goulburn Valley region in the event that SPC Ardmona closes its operations, it is clear that Victorian manufacturing – once the mainstay of the state economy.
Over the past six years, Victoria’s economic model seems to have been built around endless population growth, with the state leading the nation.
Macrobusiness: Major employment shock coming to Victoria
Letter in The Age- 26th October
Leaders clueless
It is no wonder Lord Mayor Robert Doyle is encouraging population growth. It is the only economic input keeping the state and Melbourne, in particular, from sinking into recession. But population growth will not sustain Victoria. Eventually the added load on its underfunded and underplanned infrastructure will collapse and we will be in a highly perilous state, if we aren't already. The latest CommSec, State of the States, report paints a dismal picture for Victoria. Unemployment at a 10-year high, collapsing commercial and industrial investment and wages lagging behind inflation.
We need to be asking the parties what they plan to do to lift Victoria out of this tired and unsustainable population-driven economy. How will they create a sustainable economy with real wealth and employment growth? The problem is, our leaders and would-be leaders are very quiet regarding this debate because they don't have a clue.
Bernard Ellis, Windsor
So, we are locked into an economic model based on never-ending growth, and no politician has the courage to bear the brunt of a circuit-breaker - into a recession! With housing the main economic activity, in Victoria, houses and towers must continually be built, even where there's no infrastructure, and the approval system continually deregulated and fast-tracked, to camouflage our economy's inherent weakness!
So, even an iconic, semi-rural area out of Melbourne such as the Macedon district can't be protected from over-development! The real estate Ponzi scheme consumes everything in it's wake, and can't be stopped by runaway housing growth!
The only way is out!
Relevance of Syria's free universities to discussion about Gough
The following was posted to a discussion about Gough Whitlam on johnquiggin.com.
J-D wrote:
... discussion of the present government of Syria and discussion of the present government of Russia have only a tenuous connection to the original post ...
Gough's attempt to introduce free tertiary education was rolled back by subsequent 'Labor' and Liberal governments to the point where a perverse debt collection industry based on buying and selling debts that students incur attending university has been established in Australia as has alo occurred in the UK and other places. Syria, in the midst of wars and a terrorist insurgency, is able to provide free tertiary education to all its citizens as I showed on October 26th, 2014 at 23:29. If Syria can do it, why can't Australia, the US and the UK? Clearly this suggests that Gough was right to attempt to make University eduction free.
The other obvious link is that Bashar is, like Gough was, the target of an attempted US 'regime change' Unlike Gough, Bashar has been more successful in stopping foreign powers meddling in his country's domestic affairs.
Petition against foreign home ownership here
Kerry's failure to nominate for President no loss to humanity
@FranBarlow (11:42 21/10/1),
Given that whistleblower Ray McGovern has labeled US Secretary of State John Kerry a "serial liar" for his repeated assertions, earlier this year, that he had proof that the Syrian Government had used chemical weapons against its own people, in order to justify an invasion of Syria (which so far has lost 195,000 lives resisting US-armed terrorists) Kerry's failures to win the 2004 Presidential elections and the Democratic Party Presidential nomination in 2008, were no great losses to humanity.
Whatever his flaws may have been, Al Gore's defeat at the 2000 Presidential elections, given the scale of tragedy that humanity had to endure at the hands of President George W.Bush since then, clearly was.
Overpopulation
The coal industry's economic powerhouse
Climate change to threaten food supplies
Immigration and population policy now on We vote for you
Live exporters set to "sue" the Commonwealth over ban
The overview ignores Immigration!
Amnesty complicit in 100s of 1000s of deaths since 1990
This is a contribution to a discussion about Gough Whitlam on johnquiggin.com .
JD @ #32 wrote:
What I posted in my previous comment was ... a direct quote from an Amnesty International magazine posted to the Web.
Have you forgotten that by peddling the Kuwaiti 'incubator babies' lie in 1990 Amnesty International national facilitated over two decades of war and sanctions against Iraq? This caused the deaths of many hundreds of thousands of Iraqis. One estimate had put the total death toll since 1990 as high as 3,300,000 including 750,000 children.
I have put together some information at candobetter.net/AboutAmnestyInternational. Be sure to watch Canadian peace activist Barrie Zwicker demolish the 1990 'incubator babies' lie used to justify that war. Please feel welcome to post further comments to that page or to here.
JD wrote:
The story said nothing about the Syrian election, so anybody discussing the election is saying nothing about that story.
88% of the 74% eligible voters voted on 3 June 2014 for Bashar al-Assad - a far greater endorsement than that given to any of the Western 'leaders' hostile to the Syrian government.
Can't you see that if at the elections of 3 June 2014, the Syrian people gave President Bashar al-Assad a far greater endorsement than has been given to any of the 'leaders' of Western governments hostile to Syria that we should be even more skeptical of Amnesty's claims that that government is brutally repressing its people?
One reason for al-Assad's popularity is the government programs, including free education, including tertiary education.
Of course, this is what Gough also tried to do. However, Paul Keating, who pretends to bear the mantle of Gough's legacy, started the privatisation of tertiary education with the introduction of HECS, the Higher Education 'Contribution' Scheme in 1989 (as I have been advised elsewhere on this blog). Let's not forget that Keating and Hawke also sent our armed forces to participate in the illegal war against Iraq in 1991 and implemented the illegal sanctions that caused so many deaths that I referred to above. As a result of that and the subsequent war of 2003, 1.3 million Iraqis fled to Syria according to Wikipedia.
Respecting Whitlam's birthplace brings us together
Ironically the casual disrespect shown to Gough Whitlam's birthplace by the NFIRB and Melbourne planning has provided Victorians with their first opportunity since the Dismissal to show how much they were offended by it and how much they appreciated and cared for Gough Whitlam. Because our society is so atomised by big business and so artfully misrepresented by our monopoly press, we lack free public forums and networks whereby we can spontaneously unite to express our opinions. Instead we are usually confined to sitting in front of televisions listening to self-important talking heads give their views or reading accounts in the press of what our opinions are supposed to be. Now we find out that, not only did many of us care about Whitlam, but we still care and he is remembered and appreciated far more than any other primeminister in this country because he was the last to stand up for the very things that his successors have so shamefully sold off and destroyed. Yes, it is indeed fascinating to realise that the policies of the Foreign Investment Review Board that invite overpopulation and wasteful destruction of established buildings, might have remained unsuspected by most Australians, if Gough Whitlam had not died just before the scheduled demolition of his birthplace by a foreign purchaser. How inconvenient for the planners and the NFIRB and how convenient for democracy and the rest of us. It is as if Gough Whitlam, a primeminister who sought to reform urban and regional development by offering the people an alternative to private land speculators and to preserve Australian assets from globalisation, is having the final word.
Bob Day criticises Albanese for high density policy
457 Visa report admits risk of free-for-all
"In submissions and interviews, both employers and employees expressed dissatisfaction with the current system, employers because they say it is inflexible and does not reflect the rapidly - changing nature of the Australian labour market, and employees because they say it is too easily subverted and, in practice, can turn into a free - for - all, to the disadvantage of Australians. "Considering the number of young people dropping out of the workforce and unemployed, this deserves more attention. However as it is buried in a lengthy report it does not surprise me that it has been largely overlooked. Read it at :- http://www.immi.gov.au/pub-res/Documents/reviews/streamlined-responsive-457-programme.pdf In the same context, Easy Migrate has been running an advertisement in the West Australian newspaper featuring their 95% success rate and offering a discounted first consultation at $60 , cf regular charge of $100, for first consult. They cover a wide range of visa and migration classes, including student, visitors and permanent settlement. Feedback from users gives an interesting insight into their wide ranging "fix almost any problem” activities. P.W.
US now forcibly quarantining Ebola risks - New York
Debate questions from audience
What's happening to Gough's birthplace is happening to all of us
The irony is that Gough Whitlam condemned inflation caused by foreign buyers of Australia's assets.
His election speech of 1974, he said:"The Australian dollar was grossly undervalued. Foreign money was flooding in to buy up Australian resources and Australian industries on the cheap. ... By shelving the Trade Practices Bill they (The Senate) left the door open to monopolies and big corporations to fix prices, organise cartels and exploit the Australian customer. By shelving the Australian Industry Development Corporation Bill they blocked the most effective instrument for ensuring Australian control of our industries and developing new industries. They have left the door open to foreign takeovers and foreign exploitation of the Australian economy".
Election Speeches - Gough Whitlam 1974
What's happening to Whitlam's birth place is a micro example of what's happening to our houses, real estate, public assets and agricultural land. Inflation of house prices, deliberately manipulated as a "housing boom", thanks to heavy immigration and Australia being "open" to business! We are losing industries and businesses to free trade agreements and high rates of cheap imports flooding our markets!
It means peak property prices for those at the apex of the Ponzi scheme, the demolition of our heritage and traditional family homes, and foreigners owning properties that should be in the hands of Australians.
Our political leaders dwarf into nothing more than corporate spruikers instead of real leaders, showing statesmanship and patriotic fervour for a better life for Australians, and Australia as a unique and strong nation. Gough Whitlam had a vision for a fair and equitable Australia, with a strong singular identity, with high standards of living and nationalism. Now, we are enslaved to mortgages, renting (from foreign landlords), privatisation of public assets, paying heavy debt for a tertiary education and overloaded health care system!
Forum discussion about Gough Whitlam on JohnQuiggin.com
James
See Christopher Boyce: Burial of Gough's legacy continued after 1975, above.
Sheila Newman
Gough’s policies showed that he was well aware that the long boom was ending; he engaged with a project for energy self-sufficiency. Arguable, had he not been deposed, he might have made Australia independent, like so many other oil-producing countries of the era. (We no longer produce much oil at all, having used it all or exported it.) For more on this see “Another take on Whitlam, Population, Energy Resources, and the Khemlani loan scandal” at http://candobetter.net/node/4135. When I was engaged in a research thesis that I finished in 2002, I approached the history of the Whitlam government at an angle from which it had not previously been approached.
John Brookes
So what do we aim for? I don’t see much point in starting with the leadership of the ALP. We need to start with a vision of a world we want. Unless we have a vision, how can we sell it?
In many ways we need to go back to Gough. He wanted equality of opportunity, hence the free education and health care. Where do we go?
I look at life a bit like a game of footy on the school oval. The best game has everybody playing. But more and more we have too many people sitting on the side lines, not really wanted or needed. Out there on the oval, if the game doesn’t work for the majority of kids, then it breaks up. Kids start changing the rules until the game works again.
But right now, to stretch an analogy, we have the kids who are getting all of the footy telling us that this is the only way that footy works.
So we need someone to step up with a clear vision for remaking society so that it works for more people. Back in 1972, the conservative world was looking more and more ridiculous. Change seemed inevitable. But back in that era, there was a youth movement. They really wanted change. When I look at today's uni students, my main worry is that they are too trusting and may end up being sorely disappointed when they do all the right things and life doesn’t work out for them. We’ve already put home ownership out of reach of many.
James
This comment is 'awaiting moderation' - JS, 01:14 +10:00 25 Oct 2014
John Brooks @ #9 wrote:
@James
So what do we aim for? I don't see much point in starting with the leadership of the ALP. We need to start with a vision of a world we want. Unless we have a vision, how can we sell it?
Apologies for being so slow to respond, and apologies and that my initial response is so brief:
If you look around the world in 2014, as well as military aggression, mass murder and tyranny, there is much in the world to give us hope, but only if you remember to believe almost nothing that you read about today's geopolitical conflicts in the mainstream media .
Whilst despots, fraudsters, gangsters and fascists run much of the world, much of the rest of the world is run by people who are every bit as humane and decent as Gough was.
However, unlike Gough, they have shown themselves to be far more capable of standing up for themselves and their countries against the global forces of darkness. Of course, those same leaders are demonised by the mainstream media.
Two striking examples are Syrian President Bashar al-Assad and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Contrary to the implication manufactured by msm 'reports', both have not only been elected in certifiably democratic elections, both enjoy domestic popularity which dwarfs that of any Western leader I can think of - Tony Abbott, Barack Obama, Francois Hollande, David Cameron, Stephen Harper, Angela Merkel, Kevin Rudd, John Howard, Paul Keating, Bob Hawke, Malcolm Fraser and even Gough in 1972 and 1974.
Presidents al-Assad and Putin have also shown themselves to be far more willing to confront critical media scrutiny than any of today's Western 'leaders'. I have watched a number of interviews where both were able to demolish what has been peddled as 'news' to Western audiences. No doubt, Gough would have been able to do the same before a far less unbalanced international mass media.
Some good web sites are:
globalresearch -dot- ca, voltairenet.org, presstv -dot- com, landdestroyer -dot- blogspot -dot- com, rt -dot- com (as well as my own web site, candobetter -dot -net).
By all means, continue to read the printed msm and watch and listen to the msm broadcast media, John Brookes, but I think, over time, you will see, when you are able to compare their narratives with those on the sites such as those listed above, that little truth is to be found there.
Suggestion bushfire mitigation election policy
James,
Great suggested policies!
How about adding a bushfire mitigation policy of "Pause and review" regarding prescribed burning of Victorian Bushland. It is killing all the wildlife and, arguably, within 20 years all habitat would be so devoid of wildlife and so reduced in quality that it would all have been destroyed, to all intents and purposes. Any routine burning should only be conducted very judiciously near human infrastructure, if at all.
Hans Brunner has added the following excellent summary of the arguments:
"Before you burn think four times:
1. It kills wildlife
2. It adds to air pollution.
3. It prohibits the area to work as a carbon sink.
4. The blackened area absorbs more heat."
Maybe incorporate this?
War Culture
by David Swanson , first published on warisacrime.org, 23 Oct 2014
According to a book by George Williston called This Tribe of Mine: A Story of Anglo Saxon Viking Culture in America, the United States wages eternal war because of its cultural roots in the Germanic tribes that invaded, conquered, ethnically cleansed, or -- if you prefer -- liberated England before moving on to the slaughter of the Native Americans and then the Filipinos and Vietnamese and on down to the Iraqis. War advocate, former senator, and current presidential hopeful Jim Webb himself blames Scots-Irish American culture.
But most of medieval and ancient Europe engaged in war. How did Europe end up less violent than a place made violent by Europe? Williston points out that England spends dramatically less per capita on war than the United States does, yet he blames U.S. warmaking on English roots. And, of course, Scotland and Ireland are even further from U.S. militarism despite being closer to England and presumably to Scots-Irishness.
"We view the world through Viking eyes," writes Williston, "viewing those cultures that do not hoard wealth in the same fashion or make fine iron weapons as child-like and ripe for exploitation." Williston describes the passage of this culture down to us through the pilgrims, who came to Massachusetts and began killing -- and, quite frequently, beheading -- those less violent, acquisitive, or competitive than they.
Germans and French demonstrated greater respect for native peoples, Williston claims. But is that true? Including in Africa? Including in Auschwitz? Williston goes on to describe the United States taking over Spanish colonialism in the Philippines and French colonialism in Vietnam, without worrying too much about how Spain and France got there.
I'm convinced that a culture that favors war is necessary but not sufficient to make a population as warlike as the United States is now. All sorts of circumstances and opportunities are also necessary. And the culture is constantly evolving. Perhaps Williston would agree with me. His book doesn't make a clear argument and could really have been reduced to an essay if he'd left out the religion, the biology metaphors, the experiments proving telepathy or prayer, the long quotes of others, etc. Regardless, I think it's important to be clear that we can't blame our culture in the way that some choose to blame our genes. We have to blame the U.S. government, identify ourselves with humanity rather than a tribe, and work to abolish warmaking.
In this regard, it can only help that people like Williston and Webb are asking what's wrong with U.S. culture. It can be shocking to an Israeli to learn that their day of independence is referred to by Palestinians as The Catastrophe (Nakba), and to learn why. Similarly, many U.S. school children might be startled to know that some native Americans referred to George Washington as The Destroyer of Villages (Caunotaucarius). It can be difficult to appreciate how peaceful native Americans were, how many tribes did not wage war, and how many waged war in a manner more properly thought of as "war games" considering the minimal level of killing. As Williston points out, there was nothing in the Americas to compare with the Hundred Years War or the Thirty Years War or any of the endless string of wars in Europe -- which of course are themselves significantly removed in level of killing from wars of more recent years.
Williston describes various cooperative and peaceful cultures: the Hopi, the Kogi, the Amish, the Ladakh. Indeed, we should be looking for inspiration wherever we can find it. But we shouldn't imagine that changing our cultural practices in our homes will stop the Pentagon being the Pentagon. Telepathy and prayer are as likely to work out as levitating the Pentagon in protest. What we need is a culture dedicated to the vigorous nonviolent pursuit of the abolition of war.
Christopher Boyce: Burial of Gough's legacy continued after 1975
The following is a contribution to a discussion in response to John Quiggin's artcle Gough Whitlam (23/10/14).
Thank you, Professor Quiggin. I find the above a helpful guide to Gough's achievements that his successors and the mainstream media have tried to bury.
However, as noted by Christopher Boyce in "The Falcon Lands" episode of SBS Dateline of 18 February, the subversion of Australian democracy by no means ended in 1975. It continued until the influence of all who shared Gough's vision was marginalised within the Labor Party by the likes of Bob Carr, Paul Keating and Peter Beattie.
John Quiggin wrote:
With the failure of the global financial system now evident to all, social democratic parties have found themselves largely unable to respond.
I think that supposed social-democratic parties of the twenty-first century have shown that they are unwilling, rather than 'unable' to respond.
John Quiggin continued:
We need a renewed movement for a fairer society and a more functional economy. We can only hope for a new Whitlam to lead that movement.
So, let's try to bring that about. A good start would be the repudiation of leaders of the Labor Party, mentioned above, who have attempted to bury Labor's traditional program and have, instead, embraced economic neoliberalism and privatisation.
Irony of Matthew Guy saving Gough's house
Ironic that if Gough had set policies for Australia today
(a) built property would not have gone to a foreign buyer
(b) there would not have been incentive to destroy established houses
(c) population pressure would hardly exist
(d) we would not have developers running parliament and changing laws in their industry's favour and against citizens
Pity that Matthew doesn't step in and save homes from the East West Link.
Oh Vale Gough! Vale!
Gough's birth place saved?
Reduce social security payments by reducing immigration
Australia "running on empty"
An NRMA-commissioned report on the nation’s liquid fuel security, released in February, says that Australia’s liquid fuel stocks have slumped by 16 per cent in less than a year and that the country is now hurtling towards 100 per cent dependence on imported liquid fuel and oil for transport. Even our Defence Force will be relying on imported fuel.
Australia’s Liquid Fuel Security report is the second part of an inaugural study released last year and paints a bleak picture of a country which it says does not have a viable level of fuel security, or a government plan to improve the situation at a time when local refineries are closing.
According to the company, Australia now sources 90% of its crude and fuel imports for transport, up from just 60% in 2000. Even the Australian Navy is feeling the heat with news that the domestic supply of a special type of fuel will no longer be refined locally by mid-2014.
The NRMA-commissioned report on the nation’s liquid fuel security warns that Australia’s severely declining oil refining industry, and increasing demand for liquid fuels, could result in a scenario in 2030 where it has less than 20 days worth of fuel in reserve, and 100 per cent imported liquid fuel dependency. It's a threat to our nation's security. The report, updated by Jamison in 2010, proposed a series of steps to end Australia’s dependence on imported oil and secure its own transport energy future.
China, India, and other developing countries in Asia account for 72 per cent of the net world increase in liquid fuels consumption, with Middle East consumers accounting for another 13 per cent.
Twenty-eight per cent of the refining industry is set to close by the end of this year, according to report's author, retired Air Vice-Marshal Blackburn. The former deputy head of the RAAF also accused previous reviews of energy security of being purely economic. He urged the government to consider dropping barriers to the adoption of gas as vehicle fuel and to work with the refining industry to retain capacity in Australia. However, our LNG is being sold off at export prices for the overseas market!
The Reserve Our Gas coalition will not apologise for pointing out Australia is the only gas-exporting nation on earth allowing a free-for-all on the export of its gas. Australian gas prices are projected to triple over coming years as a result.
“Let me make this absolutely crystal clear: Australia is the only nation on earth allowing multinational gas companies to extract our gas - without restriction - and sell it back to us at the high global price,” AWU National Secretary and Reserve Our Gas spokesperson Mr McDine said.
According to the ABS, renewable energy extraction, which has been steadily increasing since 2008-09, decreased in 2011-12 by 15 PJ and remains at 2% of total domestic energy production. Solar energy extraction increased by 3 PJ, or 21% and hydro-electricity supply, which fluctuates according to water availability, decreased by 10 PJ, or 16%. Our government's belief in the cornucopia myth, and anti-science stance, could finally jeopardize the eternal "growth" paradigm!
Demolition of Gough's birth place
Live export system is failing, and is unable to protect animals
Whitlam lowered immigration levels
Lowest rate of foreign ownership was under Whitlam
Time to leave
Whitlam's greatest plan was buying back Australian assets
Gough
Lack of intellectual capacity crippling Australia
Melbourne is going skyhigh, as so are complaints
People are complaining because of lack of planning - and what's happening is that Melbourne and it's suburbs are being wantonly surrendered to property developers and planners for their vested interests. Behind the "population growth" is demographic engineering, or massive increases in net overseas immigration - not organic or natural reproductive rates!
Between 2000 and 2001, net overseas immigration numbers were are about 80.000. Now the numbers have soared to 241,000 permanent immigration and set to increase again next year. (not counting humanitarian intake or New Zealanders who do not require a visa).
The public are not being given any right to query the overwhelming of Melbourne by housing growth, and suburbs being forced to accept high density housing at the detriment of living standards and traditional values.
We need some real economic activities, not just a heavy reliance on the overly easy option of housing - and the downstream costs of population growth.
Any other method of stimulating our economy, apart for amassing people, would take innovation, thought, planning and intellectual capacity. Population growth, the selling off of our housing and "lifestyle", is a no-brainer and an easy option. Real economic growth requires investment in productivity, knowledge industries, and creativity, A flow of immigrants is a short-term option, one that produces cash flows but downstream accumulates massive infrastructure debts, and actually dilutes the "lifestyle" that's being promoted!
As writer Donald Horne said, "Australia is a Lucky Country, run mainly by second-rate people who share its luck".
SMH:Melbourne going skyhigh but so are complaints about planning at http://www.smh.com.au/national/education/melbournes-going-skyhigh-but-so-are-complaints-about-planning-20141016-116vxe.html
Oliver Stone to produce biopic on Edward Snowden
Liabilities as an assett
Australians the world's richest thanks to property
Animal Justice Party to contest Victorian elections
From Animal Justice Party trots, waddles and runs for Parliament (4/10/14) by Farah Tomazin from the Age:
It was a pre-election rally for creatures great and small.
Some wanted jumps racing banned. Others wanted a genuine crackdown on puppy farms. And some called for an end to ducks being killed in the name of sport.
With eights weeks until the state election, activists, politicians, pets and owners gathered on the steps of state parliament on Saturday united by a single cause: animal welfare.
The newest micro party to be registered this week - the Animal Justice Party – used the forum to put the major parties on notice, particular in the upper house, where the balance of power is up for grabs.
More than 20 candidates would contest November's poll, convener Bruce Poon declared, "and they're standing for, and on behalf of animals, who can't do it for themselves."
The crowd also called for jumps racing to be banned. However, Dr Napthine – who is also Victoria's racing minister – is a strong supporter of jumps racing and argues that government investment has improved safety over the years.
Editorial comment: Whilst candobetter.net fully endorses the Animal Justice Party, having a large number of 'micro-parties' like the Animal Justice Party contesting the ballot poses problems for Victorian voters. As the article above indicates, a large number of issues, apart from animal justice will be decided on 29 November. It is our hope that each Victorian voter will be given an opportunity to vote for at least one candidate, in his/her own electorate as well as in the upper house, who takes what we consider to be the correct, principled stance on all of the issues listed above including animal justice.
Were a voter to be be faced with a number of candidates each supporting only a single, if laudable cause, we recommend that that voter get around this with the preferential voting system. If she/he decides to give her/his first preference to the Animal Justice Party, then she/he should give her/his second, then third and fourth preferences to other candidates who are in favour of some or all of the other policies listed above and he/she should be sure to put preferences for those parties ahead of preferences for either of the major party candidates. It may make a difference, particularly in the upper house.
Colonialism/Imperialism never left
Stealing Africa's doctors backfires on 'First' world countries
diseases spreading through massive migrations
With massive population growth over the last decades, migration of people across the globe has increased tremendously. Moreover, flooding, desertification and other predicted impacts of climate change could force millions of others to migrate. The global stock of international migrants was around 231 million in 2013, representing 3% of the world’s population.
In today's globally connected world, one infected person can carry a disease from any place in the world to another within 24 hours.
Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) describes Ebola as "one of the world's most deadly diseases." "It is a highly infectious virus that can kill up to 90% of the people who catch it, causing terror among infected communities," it says.
With every connecting flight carrying passengers who have recently been in the Ebola-ravaged countries of Sierra Leone, Guinea or Liberia, the chances of another exportation of the disease increases. The World Health Organization says West Africa could see up to 10,000 new Ebola cases a week within two months, dramatically up from the 9,000 cases reported so far, about half of whom have died.
Several African nations have restricted or banned air travel from Ebola-stricken countries, and airlines including Kenya Airways, British Airways, Air Cote D’Ivoire and Nigeria's Arik Air have suspended flights from the countries.
If a Western country is truly intent on keeping Ebola out, it has to go further than banning direct flights from the worst-affected places and must also target global hubs.
In all of this discussion what's been lost or ignored is that unchecked immigration from the third world brings with it third world problems. In the past 50 years, a total of 900 cases of leprosy affected the American population. Today because of massive immigration from third world countries, 7,000 Americans suffer with leprosy. It is a mystery why the United States allows any travelers at all to fly from the Ebola-infected countries of West Africa into American airports. A deeper answer is that much of the American establishment has bought into “post-America”—the concept that the border shouldn’t mean much of anything.
SARS and Swine Flu demonstrated only too well how quickly infections can spread around the world accompanying human movement and ebola threatens to follow the same route.
On JQ: Victorian elections & plans to flog off Port of Melbourne
This was posted to the article on the John Quiggin blog site referred to above
Below I include, as an appendix, what I had mistakenly posted on 16 October to "Yesterdays' Enemies, ..." (7/10/14), instead of "Monday message Board" (6/10/14).
In Victoria, both major parties are committed to flogging of the Port of Melbourne whoever wins government on 29 November.
As the events in Queensland show, our best hope of blocking assets sales lies with good independent or small party candidates being elected to Parliament on 29 November.
In the hope of helping to bring this about, I have posted to my web-site the article linked to in the appendix.
James
Appendix: Issues that should be decided at the 29 November Victorian State elections
Victorian voters could on Saturday 29 November begin take back their state Parliament from the vested interests that are now running Victoria.
If presented with open, informed discussion there is every reason to hope that a far larger proportion of Victorians than in previous years will vote for good independent or small party candidates and not for either of the two major parties.
...
If you support these policies, and you know of a candidate in your electorate who also supports these polices, please consider offering to help him/her. Alternatively, if there is no candidate who supports these policies standing in your electorate or upper house region, the why not consider nominating yourself?
...
Agree about rediscovering society
Rediscovery of society more so than patriotism
Doyle did not have any solution
Independents to block asset sales in Qld - John Quiggin
See Quiggan's article below. What a saga. In 2009 James Sinnamon stood as an independent on this issue and the ABC simply refused to publicise it and the commercial press would also hardly touch it. James Sinnamon would have stood as an independent against asset sales in 2010, had he not been put into a coma by a car accident. I remember watching in frustration as the corrupt land-speculating and asset-selling Queensland Labor Government lost government due to its constant privatisations. In the absence of any party running against privatisations (the Greens and the Socialist Alliance parties were totally suspect and limp on this), the only 'alternative' was the LNP which, predictably, just went on to flog more assets. Now, finally, some independents are taking up the issue! And, apparently, it is getting a little publicity. However, the powers that be are benefiting from privatisations, so, if there is anything left to privatise in Queensland, they will suppress these alternatives' messages as well.
Independents to block asset sales in Qld
by John Quiggin
The ABC reports that eight independent and minor party MPs in the Queensland Parliament have agreed to vote against the government's asset sales plan (spuriously called a lease). This has several implications
* Most obviously, if neither major party wins a majority at the next election, the asset sales won't go ahead
* Since most voters don't like asset sales, this increases the likelihood of existing independents holding their seats and perhaps of others winning seats, so that a minority government becomes more likely
* Polling isn't very helpful here, since the "two-party preferred" measure isn't relevant in these circumstances, and the sample size is too small too tell us about which seats will go which way
* In the event of neither party winning a majority, the chance of a Labor minority government is enhanced by the fact that asset sales will be a key issue
* Everything is further complicated by the fact that, if the LNP lose their majority, Campbell Newman will almost certainly lose his seat in the process
I don't bet on elections any more after I couldn't collect my winnings from Intrade (long story), but a bet on Annastacia Palaszczuk as the next premier looks a lot more promising than it did yesterday (of course, there's always the truly bizarre possibility that some other Labor MP could challenge here - they need to rule it this kind of nonsense ASAP)
Doyle shows callous contempt and complete indifference
Forests - It's a war-zone out there for wildlife
Moonie Valley joins the fight vs East West Link
Italy end their rescue of migrants, for border control
No evidence of who shot down MH17
You will not make Australia Home!
Lord Mayor's solution to "affordable housing"?
Lord Mayor Doyle's solution to creating "affordable housing" is all too convenient for the housing, mortgage and construction industries! He thinks we can solve the problem by racing to keep building more and more apartments and units! With population growth running at full throttle levels, the prices are kept high because demand is outstripping supply, and prices have flowed over any level of affordability for first home buyers! Melbourne is becoming more "vibrant" with all the homeless living in the streets. With zero net immigration, and a referendum on population growth, we could actually manage to drop prices and housing would become affordable. However, the power elite are gouging the public with record house prices, and of course would obviously say that our population growth was "inevitable" and impossible to do anything about!
Lord Mayor v.s. Hon. Kelvin Thomson MP
NSW TAFE has been destroyed
TAFE NSW has been destroyed by the current government and the former government, making TAFE compete with private education. It will never work unless TAFE is privatised with its current business structure and constant holiday breaks TAFE cannot complete, courses need to run all year round if they are going to compete. I am former Web Design teacher at the Cessnock Campus and can say there are too many people in positions they should never be in making really bad decisions.
Editorial comment: Some corrections have been made.
In general candobetter favours more holiday times rather than fewer and shorter working hours by reducing both the legal requirement to work those hours and the economic compulsion to do so. The most common economic compulsions to work long hours are high rent and high mortgage repayments. The working conditions of TAFE college staff sound closer to what we would consider ideal. We would certainly be against the privatisation of TAFE colleges. In any case there already plenty of private training institutions.
This comment included a link to http://hunterwebmasters.com with the label "Learn Web Development free". Quite possibly there may be some site visitors who will find your services useful. We wish you well in your business, but in general candobetter is not a web-site on which to advertise commercial businesses. - Ed
Kelvin Thomson clearly the winner!
Bill Shorten in favour of a ‘big Australia’
New patriotic drive needed in Australia
If rich countries want to help Africa, stop poaching our doctors
Ending the Invasion
Invasion of Australia orchestrated by members of parliament
National sovreignty is at stake
What is "homonormativity"?
Anthony Albanese opposes Australian 'anti-terror' laws
Albanese breaks ranks on anti-terror laws
Sunday 12 Oct 14 adapted from SkyNews. Also reported in the Sydney Morning Herald, News.com, The Australian and the Guardian
The Greens and Independent MP Andrew Wilkie moved unsuccessful bids to have Australia's commitment debated by the parliament, with the government and Labor blocking their attempts.
Anthony Albanese hit back at the lack of scrutiny over the measures describing the penalties on the media as draconian.
There was public interest in exposing errors of security agencies, he said.
"You can be fully supportive of our engagement in the Middle East and still say we don't protect freedom by giving it up," Mr Albanese told Sky News.
Mr Albanese said he was "not a pacifist" and believed the world could not sit by and watch the brutality of Islamic State, but the parliament should still be consulted.
Mr Albanese concerns may be too little too late.
Labor waved the bill through parliament, citing bipartisan support for national security.
Asked if Opposition Leader Bill Shorten shared his concerns about press freedom, Mr Albanese said: 'I'm speaking for myself.'
...
'We should be arguing for more scrutiny of these issues,' Mr Albanese said.
Security agencies are trying to impose things that have been in their bottom draw for a long time, Mr Albanese said.
Foreign investors buying up our houses and building towers
Seems like 451 Visas take all jobs in St Kilda
Block Auction
Australia heading for worst joblessness in the Asia-Pacific
The faster population grows, the faster poverty grows
Water availability a good illustration
Anson Cameron, "Does growing Melbourne mean a short shower?"
This fabulous article raises the absurd and dystopian push for a big population by Robert Doyle and Denis Napthine, in a long line of leaders who apparently do not give a stuff about the people of Melbourne. I would have liked us to have reproduced it in full, but I cannot get hold of the mass media outlets to ask permission, so can only post a portion. However anyone can click on the links. Please do. It makes the points brilliantly.
"A couple of years back the Victorian government posted me a little blue egg-timer. It has Our Water stamped on one end and Our Future stamped on the other and a suction cup so I can stick it on my shower wall and watch the blue sand run for four minutes while I wash.
People I know who remembered World War II saw this as rationing and felt edgy and suspected we were facing a dark enemy. I felt the unease myself as I frantically washed while the pretty sand ran.
A few months later the same government announced they were opening up land on the urban boundaries on Melbourne's north and west for another 450,000 people. An addition the size of Canberra. Insert double-blink here. We haven't got enough water to shower longer than a U2 ballad and you're smilingly telling me what? Recently D. Napthine triumphantly announced a new suburb called Rockbank would be built. Which allowed those of us who were worried Sydney and/or Brisbane might edge ahead of us in some fatuous ranking of national and/or international importance to relax.
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/does-growing-melbourne-mean-a-short-shower-20141002-10oyxe.html#ixzz3Fni2INZ8
Letter to QLD Minister for Police re kangaroo management
Is 'OpenH264 Video Codec' causing delayed keystrokes?
We all use the internet if we read candobetter.net, so others among you may have been encountering a huge problem of delayed keystrokes - i.e., when you try to reply to emails, write emails, you have to wait for ages while Firefox deliberates for some reason. It slows down your work and causes stress. It makes you want to avoid looking at your inbox.
I went to my add-ons settings in Firefox and disabled the following program:
OpenH264 Video Codec provided by Cisco Systems Inc. 1.1
It seemed to solve my problem immediately. Let me know if you have a similar experience.
Feral cats tear through last wild bilby population in Queensland
Turkey helped build ISIS & now poses as Syrian Kurds' saviour
ISIS, Turkey, and the Propaganda of Intervention (10/10/14) by Eric Draitser on both Global Research and the Land Destroyer Report explains the duplicitous role of Turkish President Erdogan that is now attempting to ethnically cleanse Kurds from the North of Syria and help overthrow the government of President Bashar al-Assad.
The article explains at least as well as any other article I have read, the complex and deceitful dynamics of the purportedly anti-Western rebellion of ISIS in Iraq and Syria.
However, in this otherwise excellent article, Eric Draitser, as do, unfortunately, a number of other supporters of Syria, labels President Bashar al-Assad's government "the Assad regime". Has Eric forgotten so that President Assad was overwhelmingly elected in the Presidential election of 4 June, the authenticity of which was attested to by International observers at a press conference held the United Nations on 19 June?
Such denial of the democratic legitimacy of Syrian President Bashar Al-Assad can only help the enemies of Syria.
Thanks
This is a decent tips particularly to those new to blogosphere, short and precise data… Thanks for imparting this one. An unquestionable requirement read article... eazaxdcj
eazaxdcj (?) - Ed
East West Link will employ 457 visa holders!
To add injury to insult, the Victorian Government has been forced to fend off concerns about foreign workers being hired to build Melbourne's East West Link road project.
Spanish company Acciona, contracted to do some of the construction, has advertised for an immigration adviser to fill a six-month contract at its Southbank office.
This means they will be using immigration services to employ 457 workers!
ACTU President Ged Kearney said it was "outrageous" for temporary workers to be brought in from overseas when unemployment was around 6.8 per cent in Victoria. Apparently we don't have the skills and specific expertise on digging tunnels, like foreigners might have!
"I am unaware of whether there is sufficient local expertise to man and operate that tunnel-boring machine," Premier Napthine said! What about some skill training, on operating the machines. The trainers are the only experts we need from overseas, not the workers!
The secret business plan for the EWL is about sustaining the road lobby, with a new port and airports in the west of Victoria to fly in and transport all the goods from China, to distribute commodities and fill our shopping centres with saleable and imported goods we are failing to produce here!
See also: 457 Visa: East West Link to have up to 35 foreign workers - Herald Sun (8/10/14), East West Link contract winners shout top public servants dinner at Vue de Monde - Age (8/10/14).
Please don't despair! There's a state election coming up on Saturday 29 November. All those who are in any way complicit in this rort can be held to account and made to regret this shameful conduct. - Ed
Koala habitat being destroyed by housing developments
There is 108-hectare of land currently under planning minister Pru Goward’s determination for large-scale housing/industrial development, and sits just 2.5 kilometres west of the CBD in Byron Bay.
The Echo newspaper understands that Sydney-based developer Terry Agnew is by far the largest shareholder at around 80 per cent, along with other local investors. The matter is being referred to the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC)
Local state MP Don Page (Nationals) and members from the Byron Residents Group last week to discuss a full range of issues ie koalas, traffic, population projections, acid sulfate soils, vegetation, environment zones etc. They supplied additional information on koalas. Mr Page said some of the issues include 'traffic congestion, environmental issues including vegetation, koalas and acid sulfate soils; and potential flooding.’
West Byron development proposal referred ICAC
The Australian Koala Foundation raised concerns that koala populations were in decline across Brisbane, Redlands and Logan. During Save the Koala Month in September the AKF called for tighter legislation to protect the marsupial, which is threatened by urban development. But Environment Minister Andrew Powell assured that existing legislation was adequate, saying developers were required to offset clearing of koala habitat by planting new trees. Existing legislation was hardly "adequate" as "offsets" result in net habitat loss!
Debate over the health of koala populations continues as dogs bought in to track the marsupials
There's all sorts of reservation, protection, conservation schemes, but the housing industry is like a huge tsunami of urbanization, destroying everything in it's way. It leave a wreckage of concrete, traffic and loss of wildlife, but with little economic activities in Australia - due to the facing mining industries - housing and population keeps growing relentlessly and lethally.
Australia's "shortage" of doctors due to exporting education
Confusion re 400 bodies in East Ukraine
Although there are certainly mass graves, it seems likely that the number of 400 bodies does not refer to mass graves alone. In the video below it seems thaThere is a discussion about the origins of this confusion in the video below. Following that report there is another very good comment on a rumour that IS is threatening to infiltrate Europe by sending people to masquerade as refugee applicants.
East West Link: Lend Lease and Tax Avoidance
Evidence is in the consequences
If we don't stop it Melbourne will double in 35 yrs
4 Corners program: Edward Snowden on NSA & Silicon Valley
On Four Corners at 8:80PM AEDT Mon 6 Oct 2014, repeated 11:35PM AEDT Tue 7 Oct or watch on-line or on IView : Privacy Lost
Monday 6th October 2014
When a contractor from America's National Security Agency (NSA) downloaded tens of thousands of top-secret documents from a highly secure Government network, it led to the largest leak of classified information in history - and sparked a fierce debate over privacy, technology and democracy in the post-9/11 world.
In leaking the files, Edward Snowden had not only exposed classified information, he also exposed how the US Government had co-opted major tech companies to help it spy on millions of people in the United States and around the world - including Australians.
That surveillance did not simply mean detailing the source and destination of communication, but the communications themselves.
...
Critical appraisal: Coming from 4 Corners, which has copped out on issues like MH17, JFK, the Boston Bombing, 9/11 and most foreign conflicts, this program is surprisingly good.
Are women with burkas/niqabs expected to work?
Hold a referendum on population growth.
The Burqa- the challenge of Multiculturalism in Australia
Man will take legal action after rangers took pet kangaroos
AN Apple Tree Creek man, Colin Candy, will take legal action after 10 officers from the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection and Queensland Parks and Wildlife arrived at his home to seize five of his kangaroos. Police officers, and a vet, all came unannounced with a warrant to seize the offending animals - his red kangaroos!
He didn't have a permit to keep the kangaroos, but he insists he's doing it to rescue and protect them. "Kangaroos are treated like pariahs in their own country so I don't understand why I can't keep them. They are harmless beautiful creatures who don't come out of the bush to hurt you like tigers. I applied for a permit numerous times in the past and have only been rejected".
"Only rescue permits are given out." Plenty of permits are given out for killing the "pests", but they are not meant to be protected and secured.
Under the Nature Conservation Act 1992, there is no provision for taking or keeping kangaroos or wallabies with a view to domesticating them.
Man will take legal action after rangers took pet kangaroos
If the gates are left open and the kangaroos continue to stay in the safety of their homes, it should be their choice. On the other hand, if they leave they are likely to be victims of traffic collisions, or lethally "managed" - killed!
This action by Parks and Wildlife is not about concern for animals, but the contradictory nature of keeping what they consider to be "pest" animals that must be controlled - lethally!
In 2001, the Queensland Parks and Wildlife officers raided his home and seized his Kangaroo, Mitchell and in November the same year his beloved Marcy was taken away. Both kangaroos died shortly after being taken away.
It's a threat to have these magnificent and threatened native red kangaroos seen to be safe, domesticated and safe! They are meant to be raging wild animals, causing threats to fences, grasslands, farmers, and wreckers of our country - ready to attack or kill any intruders on their land. Having kangaroos kept by the public is a threat to the myth of kangaroos are vermin and pests, and that's not in the interests of the Queensland government.
Pam H wrote: " 'the seizure was a culmination of a long standing investigation.' They make it sound like some great drug bust operation ffs! This country is going down the toilet fast. And we're paying for it"!
Other articles about Colin Candy: Kangaroo pet keeper loses High Court appeal (5/12/13), Farmers call to cull roos to prevent damage to grazing land (1/8/13), Animal rights group may come to roo man's rescue (29/7/13), Bitter battle for kangaroos changes Hervey Bay man's life (14/7/13), Court denies man right to keep roo he rescued and raised (31/5/13), Hopping mad, Colin rues long court row to keep roo (27/4/13).
Iraqi soldiers drive ISIL out of Zumar & head to help Syria
This is a somewhat hopeful new report from Press TV (Sat Oct 4, 2014 1:17PM GMT) at http://www.presstv.ir/detail/2014/10/04/381026/iraq-army-retakes-northern-town/ The original article also contains a short video report. Below is the text:
"Iraqi army soldiers, supported by the Kurdish Peshmerga forces and local tribesmen, have driven Takfiri ISIL militants out of the entire town of Zumar in Iraq’s northern province of Nineveh.
An Iraqi Kurdish official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said on Saturday that Iraqi troops have managed to fully clear the town, situated about 60 kilometers (37 miles) northwest of the militant-controlled city of Mosul, of the ISIL terrorists.
The official further noted that Iraqi army forces are now heading to the town of Sanjar near the border with conflict-stricken Syria.
ISIL militants launched an offensive on Zumar between August 1 and August 4, 2014, and eventually seized the town. Since August 31, Kurdish Peshmerga troops and Iraqi army soldiers had captured several positions formerly held by ISIL.
Zumar’s liberation comes a day after Iraqi forces backed by Sunni tribesman and Shia volunteers took control of most of the riverside town of Dhuluiya, situated about 70 km (43 miles) north of the capital, Baghdad, from the ISIL militants.
Over two dozen ISIL terrorists, including two British nationals, were killed in the attack.
On Friday, Iraq’s Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi vowed that Iraqi forces will defeat ISIL terrorists in the near future in the light of more advances by the army backed by Sunni tribesman and Shia volunteer forces.
The ISIL controls large areas of Syria’s east and north. The group sent its militants into Iraq in June, seizing large parts of land straddling the border between Syria and Iraq.
The West and its regional allies, including Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey, are giving financial and military support to the militants.
MP/KA/SS"
It's assumed we can grow out of our budget constraints
Vote Compass - have your say on government policies
21st century politics
Live export rules still being flouted in Jordan
Treachery
Age: Union bid to expand advertisements against 457 visa scam
twitter.com/CFMEU_National:Union bid to expand 457 visa job advertisements (1/10/14)
Unions are campaigning against a proposal to abolish the requirement for employers to advertise jobs before filling them with overseas workers on 457 visas.
The Construction Forestry Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) has analysed government data showing the number of 457 visa nominations had almost doubled from 9.8 per cent to 19.1 per cent in the first six months of the introduction of labour market testing.
The rejection rate of 457 visas for occupations that were not subject to labour market testing fell only slightly, from 7.9 per cent to 7.3 per cent, over the same six months.
...
The former Labor Government introduced the requirement that employers advertised jobs in professions including engineering, nursing and technical trades before filling them with foreign workers.
CFMEU national secretary Michael O'Connor said the initiative reduced the number of 457 visa approvals when employers failed to demonstrate that no qualified Australian workers were available for the job.
Mr O'Connor said the labour market testing requirement covered about a third of occupations and had proved to be effective.
"Asking an employer to advertise a job vacancy before they make the claim they can't find somebody is not too much to ask," he said.
"Why are people using 457 workers for low-level clerical work and nursing when you have graduate nurses unemployed?"
Mr O'Connor said, despite a rise in unemployment, particularly for younger people, 108,870 people were employed on 457 visas as at June 30.
...
Mr O'Connor said the Fair Work Ombudsman had found rules for the employment of people on 457 visas had been breached in 40 per cent of cases. Most related to the underpayment of workers.
The National Union of Workers (NUW) is also campaigning against the underpayment of workers employed by chicken processing company Baiada.
Pedro Vannea started working as a boner at Baiada's chicken processing plant in South Australia in 2007 soon after migrating from Cambodia.
His job was terminated late last year after he slipped on chicken skin and injured his ankle.
The NUW successfully lodged an unfair dismissal claim against Baiada that was being appealed.
...
Traitors, not colonisers.
Mankind chomping through Nature's bounty
Australia's ecological footprint is the 13th-largest in the world - and is likely to get bigger following the repeal of the carbon tax, conservation group WWF has warned.
WWF's Living Planet Report found the demands placed on the planet are more than 50 per cent what nature can sustain. The introduction of a price on carbon was the likely cause of our country's improved ranking, but the repeal of the two-year-old carbon price scheme in July would likely see Australia go backwards in future rankings.
The new report tracks the growth or decline of more than 10,000 populations of 3038 species ranging from forest elephants to sharks, turtles and albatrosses. Humans were consuming natural resources at a rate that would require 1.5 Earths to sustain – cutting down trees faster than they mature and harvesting more fish than oceans can replace.
The report found that if the rest of the world lived like Australians, 3.6 planet's worth of natural resources would be needed to sustain the demands placed on nature. We are in serious ecological overshoot, and our growth and living standards can't be sustained, but this report simply is incomprehensible to our leaders, and general public, and business continues as usual!
Freshwater species, which have suffered a 76 per cent decline since 1970 - double that of land and marine animals. Small mammals in Australia such as bilbies, bettongs and bandicoots, which are battling predation from introduced species such as cats and foxes.
Global biodiversity suffers as humanity lives beyond its means (30/9/11) at http://www.theage.com.au/environment/global-biodiversity-suffers-as-humanity-lives-beyond-its-means-20140929-10nl6b.html
The WWF report says it expects the world’s population to exceed 9.5-billion by 2050, and half of all future population growth is expected to occur in just eight countries, six of which are in Africa.
In just 40 years as Earth's human population has nearly doubled, while there was a 39-percent drop in numbers across a representative sample of land- and sea-dwelling species. Mankind was chomping through Nature's bounty much faster than the rate of replenishment, the WWF warned.
Read more: at Startling New Evidence Confirms That Humans Are Devastating Wildlife Across The Globe http://www.businessinsider.com/afp-wildlife-numbers-halved-over-past-four-decades-wwf-2014-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/afp-wildlife-numbers-halved-over-past-four-decades-wwf-2014-9#ixzz3EwMQraeD
Forum discussion: fabricated claims of Syrian govt mass murder
This has been posted to johnquiggin.com. - JS, 1 Nov 14
JD (@ #17(?)) wrote on October 27th, 2014 at 20:29:
Why didn't you include the link? I tried to find it with a search engine and couldn't.
JD continued:
Almost certainly this is a fabrication by the same liars who gave us Russian tanks in East Ukraine, Iraqi WMDs, incubator babies, USS Liberty, the Gulf of Tonkin incident, the Warren Commission, etc.
Until you show me where you obtained this, I cannot comment further.
As for claims that the Russian government discriminates against gays: If true, this would be of concern, but compared with the monumental violations of human rights by the Kiev regime and even more monumental violations in Iraq, Libya and Syria, the prohibition of "propaganda on non-traditional sexual relations" seems almost insignificant by comparison.